Bakuchiol or retinol: which to choose, and should you take collagen?
I've just discovered bakuchiol
I've just discovered bakuchiol, a plant-based active ingredient often presented as a gentle alternative to retinol. Like many people, I was first intrigued by the promise: improving the look of fine lines, evening out skin tone and supporting firmness, while limiting the redness and peeling sometimes associated with retinol.
But the comparison needs nuance. Bakuchiol is not simply a "natural retinol". They are two different molecules, with different levels of evidence, mechanisms of action and side effects. Retinol remains one of the best-documented cosmetic actives against the visible signs of skin ageing. Bakuchiol is promising and generally better tolerated, but there are still fewer studies on it.
So I wanted to look seriously at their advantages and drawbacks, without taking the marketing claims at face value. I'll also cover collagen supplements, often associated with anti-ageing routines, and then the product I chose: BYBI Beauty Bakuchiol Skin Restore, a light 40 ml night cream containing 1% bakuchiol.
Important: this article provides general information about cosmetics and food supplements. It does not replace the advice of a dermatologist or health professional.
Bakuchiol and retinol: what exactly are we talking about?
Retinol
Retinol is a derivative of vitamin A. Once applied to the skin, it must be converted in several steps into retinoic acid, the biologically active form that acts on the skin's retinoid receptors.
This action can help to:
- stimulate cell turnover;
- gradually improve skin texture;
- reduce the appearance of some fine lines;
- reduce uneven pigmentation;
- support collagen production in the dermis;
- help with some forms of acne, depending on the product and its strength.
However, cosmetic retinol must be distinguished from medical retinoids such as tretinoin or adapalene. These are more potent and may be prescribed or regulated differently from country to country.
Retinol has one important advantage: it has more scientific and clinical hindsight than bakuchiol. On the other hand, it can cause an adjustment period with tightness, dryness, redness, a burning sensation or peeling.
Bakuchiol
Bakuchiol is a plant compound extracted notably from the seeds of Psoralea corylifolia, a plant known by several botanical names and used traditionally in some Asian pharmacopoeias.
It is not a retinoid in the chemical sense. So it is not vitamin A and does not work in exactly the same way. Experimental work does suggest, however, that it may influence some mechanisms involved in skin ageing, notably the expression of genes associated with the extracellular matrix, pigmentation and inflammation.
Bakuchiol became popular after the publication of a randomised clinical study comparing a cream containing 0.5% bakuchiol with one containing 0.5% retinol. After twelve weeks, both groups showed an improvement in some signs of photoageing, while the bakuchiol group appeared to report less irritation. The study was interesting, but it involved a small number of participants: 44 people. It would therefore be going too far to conclude that bakuchiol is always as effective as retinol.
A systematic review published in 2024 analysed the human clinical trials available on bakuchiol. Its authors conclude that the results are encouraging, but also stress the need for larger, better-controlled and longer studies.
Bakuchiol or retinol: comparing the advantages
| Criterion | Bakuchiol | Retinol |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Non-retinoid plant active | Vitamin A derivative |
| Level of evidence | Promising, but still limited | Greater and older |
| Fine lines and texture | Possible improvement with regular use | Well-documented active |
| Tolerance | Generally better tolerated | Possible irritation, especially at first |
| Sensitive skin | An interesting option, but no guarantee of no reaction | Can be hard to introduce |
| Acne | Data still limited | Some retinoids have a recognised role |
| Pregnancy | Often presented as compatible, but caution is advised | Avoid during pregnancy |
| Sun sensitivity | Does not seem to increase photosensitivity like retinol | Sun protection essential |
| Speed of results | Probably gradual | Gradual too |
| Products available | Fewer | Very many |
The advantages of bakuchiol
Bakuchiol's first advantage is its generally good tolerance. It may suit people who have tried retinol and experienced significant irritation, or those who want to start an anti-ageing routine with a gentler active.
The second advantage is that it is relatively simple to use. It does not seem to increase the skin's sensitivity to the sun in the way retinoids do. That does not mean sun protection is pointless: ultraviolet rays remain one of the main causes of skin ageing and hyperpigmentation.
Bakuchiol can also be interesting when the aim is to improve several aspects of the skin's appearance: uneven texture, dull complexion, small fine lines or lack of suppleness. But don't expect a spectacular effect within a few days. As with most cosmetic actives, consistency is essential.
The advantages of retinol
Retinol's main advantage is its stronger evidence base. It is not a miracle ingredient, but it has more clinical experience in the field of photoageing.
Retinol may be a better choice for someone looking for a well-documented anti-ageing active who is willing to build up a suitable routine gradually. It may also be more relevant when the concerns include fine lines, texture and some pigmentation irregularities at the same time.
Its drawback is that it requires more precautions. A high concentration, too-frequent use or combining it with several irritating actives can weaken the skin barrier.
The drawbacks and limits of bakuchiol
"Natural" does not automatically mean "risk-free" or "non-irritating". Bakuchiol can cause a reaction in some people, notably in case of allergy or very reactive skin.
You also need to look at the whole formula. A cream containing bakuchiol may also contain essential oils, fragrances, fragrance allergens or preservatives that can cause problems for some skin types. The main active alone is not enough to judge how well a product will be tolerated.
Another limitation: the bakuchiol concentration is not always stated. When the manufacturer states 1%, the information is more transparent, but concentration alone does not predict effectiveness. The stability of the formula, the quality of the raw materials, the packaging and regular use also play a part.
Finally, studies on bakuchiol are still too limited to guarantee effectiveness equivalent to retinol for everyone. So I prefer to present it as a possible alternative, not a universal replacement.
Important precautions with retinol
To start retinol, I would choose a moderate strength and spaced-out application, for example two evenings a week. A small amount is enough for the whole face. It is better to avoid the immediate eye area, the sides of the nose and areas that are already irritated.
I would not use retinol on the same evening as a strong acid exfoliant, a peel or another potentially irritating active. A simple moisturiser can help improve comfort.
Sun protection is essential in the morning. Even if the exact effect on photosensitivity depends on the product and the skin, a consistent anti-ageing routine must include protection against UV.
Topical retinoids are not recommended during pregnancy or when planning a pregnancy. The European Medicines Agency recommends precautionary measures with retinoids, including topical products.
As a precaution, I would also ask a health professional for advice when breastfeeding, or in case of eczema, rosacea, dermatitis, dermatological treatment or a persistent reaction.
The product: BYBI Beauty Bakuchiol Skin Restore
The product I chose is BYBI Beauty Bakuchiol Skin Restore, a light 40 ml night cream stated to contain 1% bakuchiol.
The formula listed for this product contains, among other things:
- aloe vera gel or juice;
- grapeseed oil;
- shea butter;
- emollients;
- bakuchiol;
- vitamin E;
- lavender essential oil;
- several fragrance compounds naturally present or declared, such as linalool, limonene and geraniol.
Aloe vera, plant oils and shea butter can give a nourishing, comfortable texture, particularly pleasant in the evening. Vitamin E mainly acts as an antioxidant and helps protect the formula against oxidation.
On the other hand, the presence of lavender essential oil and fragrance allergens is worth pointing out. So I would not describe this cream as completely free of fragrance or irritants. Someone with rosacea or eczema, or who has already reacted to essential oils, should proceed with caution.
Ingredient lists available online may vary between markets or reformulations. So I would always check the packaging received before use. The ingredient information available for this product is listed notably by specialist databases such as INCIdecoder and What's in My Jar.
How I would use it
I would start by applying a small amount in the evening, on clean, dry skin, two to three times a week. If my skin tolerated it well, I could gradually increase the frequency.
Before first use, I would do a patch test on a small area for 24 to 48 hours. This test does not guarantee there will be no reaction at all, but it can sometimes pick up an obvious intolerance.
I would not immediately combine this cream with several other strong actives. A simple routine would be more sensible:
- gentle cleansing;
- a small amount of BYBI Bakuchiol Skin Restore;
- possibly a moisturiser if the skin feels tight;
- sun protection in the morning.
I would not expect a visible result after a few applications. Rather, assess tolerance, hydration and the general look of the skin over several weeks.
Should you take collagen supplements?
Collagen is a structural protein abundant in the body. In the skin, it contributes notably to the structure and strength of the dermis. With age, collagen production and organisation change, which contributes to the gradual loss of firmness.
Supplements usually contain hydrolysed collagen, also called collagen peptides. It is digested into amino acids and small peptides. The body does not automatically send them to the wrinkles: this point is important. They are used by the body according to its general needs.
Some meta-analyses have reported improved skin hydration and elasticity with hydrolysed collagen. A review published in Nutrients analysed 26 randomised trials involving 1,721 participants, while highlighting biases and the need for more robust work.
However, more recent results call for caution. A meta-analysis published in 2025 found that the benefits disappeared in analyses limited to studies without industry funding or to studies judged to be of higher quality. The authors conclude that there is not, to date, sufficiently solid clinical evidence to recommend collagen as a treatment for skin ageing.
A more recent synthesis also reports favourable results, but stresses the heterogeneity of doses, collagen sources, study durations, measurement methods and risk of bias.
The possible advantages of collagen
Collagen may be an option for someone who wants to try a supplement for several weeks or a few months, provided their expectations are realistic. Any benefits seem rather modest and gradual.
I would nevertheless see collagen as an optional supplement, not the basis of an anti-ageing strategy. A diet with enough protein, sleep, physical activity, stopping smoking and sun protection are probably more important for general health and the appearance of the skin.
Limits and precautions
Collagen supplements cost money and their composition varies widely. Some products also contain vitamin C, hyaluronic acid, flavourings or other ingredients, which makes it hard to assess the effect of the collagen itself.
I would also check:
- the origin of the collagen: bovine, porcine, marine or other;
- the presence of allergens, notably fish-derived products;
- the amount actually provided per dose;
- the manufacturer's quality controls;
- statements about pregnancy, breastfeeding and current treatments.
In case of allergy, kidney disease, a special diet or medication, I would ask a health professional for advice before starting.
My verdict: which active to choose?
If I'm looking for the best-documented active and my skin tolerates vitamin A products, retinol remains an interesting benchmark.
If my skin is sensitive, if I've already reacted badly to retinol or if I want to start more gradually, bakuchiol can be a reasonable option. I would not consider it superior to retinol, but a more comfortable alternative for some people.
BYBI Beauty Bakuchiol Skin Restore seems interesting to me for its stated 1% strength, its night-cream texture and its nourishing ingredients. I would nevertheless stay alert because of the lavender essential oil and fragrance allergens in the listed formula. It could suit normal or dry skin that tolerates fragranced products well, but I would not automatically choose it for very reactive skin.
As for collagen, I see it as a secondary option, with evidence still under debate. I would not start by buying an expensive supplement before putting the basics in place: gentle cleansing, suitable hydration and daily sun protection.
In short, I would choose:
- retinol for better-documented effectiveness, if my skin tolerates it;
- bakuchiol for a gentler, more gradual approach;
- collagen only as an optional supplement, without expecting a spectacular transformation;
- sun protection as the absolute priority for preventing photoageing.
Sources
- Fanning, McGee and Ibrahim — Human Clinical Trials Using Topical Bakuchiol Formulations for the Treatment of Skin Disorders, PubMed
- Journal of Drugs in Dermatology — Review of clinical trials on bakuchiol
- Lee et al. — Effects of Oral Collagen for Skin Anti-Aging, systematic review and meta-analysis, PMC
- Myung et al. — Effects of Collagen Supplements on Skin Aging, The American Journal of Medicine
- Oral Collagen Supplementation for Skin Hydration and Elasticity, MDPI
- American Academy of Dermatology — Retinoid or retinol?
- European Medicines Agency — Updated measures for pregnancy prevention during retinoid use
- BYBI — Bakuchiol, official information on the active and the brand
- INCIdecoder — BYBI Bakuchiol Skin Restore, listed ingredients
- What's In My Jar — BYBI Bakuchiol Skin Restore, ingredient list